Blog/content/post/5-notification-system-gotify-vs-ntfy.md

---
slug: notification-system-gotify-vs-ntfy
title: Template
description:
date: 2025-06-13
draft: true
tags:
  - notification
  - ntfy
  - gotify
categories:
  - homelab
---
## Intro

To know what is going on in my homelab and be warned when something fails, I want to setup a notification system where almost anything could seamlessly send me a message that I would  receive on my mobile.

In the past I was using **Pushover**, which was great, but I want to explore new options, more modern and eventually self-hosted.

## Choose the Right Notification System

The key elements to determine the right system for me would be:
- **Android application**: mandatory, a sleek and intuitive UI is important.
- **Integration**: I want the service integrated anywhere I want to be notified.
- **Self hosted**: Host it myself is always better for privacy.

After a quick research, the most suitable tools on the market are:
- **Ntfy**
- **Gotify**

Given the comments on internet and after testing quickly both Android app, I can't really decide. I think Ntfy is the better option, but I will install and test them both to make my mind!

## Gotify

I heard about Gotify some time ago, actually before looking at other alternatives, I had that one in mind. I quickly had a look at its [documentation](https://gotify.net/docs/) and this seems to be pretty straight forward.

### Installation

As usual, I will deploy the Gotify server with `docker compose` on `dockerVM`, a VM hosting my applications as docker container. I create a new `gotify` folder in `/appli/docker/` and I copy paste my `docker-compose.yml` template in there.

`docker-compose.yml`
```yaml
services:
  gotify:
    image: gotify/server
    container_name: gotify
    volumes:
      - /appli/data/gotify/data/:/app/data
    environment:
      - TZ=Europe/Paris
      - GOTIFY_DEFAULTUSER_NAME=${GOTIFY_DEFAULTUSER_NAME}
      - GOTIFY_DEFAULTUSER_PASS=${GOTIFY_DEFAULTUSER_PASS}
    networks:
      - web
    labels:
    - traefik.enable=true
    - traefik.http.routers.gotify.rule=Host(`gotify.vezpi.me`)
    - traefik.http.routers.gotify.entrypoints=https
    - traefik.http.routers.gotify.tls.certresolver=letsencrypt
    - traefik.http.services.gotify.loadbalancer.server.port=80
    restart: always

networks:
  web:
    external: true
```

`.env`
```
GOTIFY_DEFAULTUSER_NAME=vez
GOTIFY_DEFAULTUSER_PASS=<password>
```

In the [documentation](https://gotify.net/docs/config), I can see that several database backend can be used, by default it is using **sqlite3** which will be fine for the test. Switching to **PostgreSQL** could be a thing if I decide to stick with Gotify. In that same page, I can see the different environment variables that I can use to configure the server from the `docker-compose.yml` file.

When my config files are ready, I create a new entry in my Caddy plugin in OPNsense to forward my new Gotify URL: https://gotify.vezpi.me.

I also create the folder `/appli/data/gotify/data/` in `dockerVM` to mount it as a volume and store datas:
```bash
mkdir -p /appli/data/gotify/data/
```

Finally I spin the docker stack up:
```bash
$ docker compose up -d
[+] Running 5/5
 ✔ gotify Pulled
   ✔ 63ce8e957633 Pull complete
   ✔ e7def9680541 Pull complete
   ✔ 9a1821c438b4 Pull complete
   ✔ ad316556c9ff Pull complete
[+] Running 1/1
 ✔ Container gotify  Started
```

✅ Reaching the URL https://gotify.vezpi.me gives me the Gotify login page:
![Gotify login page](img/gotify-login-page.png)

After login, I can access the dashboard, with no messages obviously:
![Gotify dashboard on a fresh installation](img/gotify-dashboard-no-messages.png)

### Creating an Application

To allow messages to be pushed, I before need to create an application for which the messages will be regrouped for. This can be done in two ways:
- **WebUI**
- **REST-API**

For the test, I will use the WebUI, I click on the `APPS` button at the top and `CREATE APPLICATION`. I choose a wonderful application name and description.
![Create an application on Gotify](img/gotify-create-new-application.png)

Once my application in created, a token is generated for it. I can edit the application to change anything, I can also upload an icon.
![Gotify application list showing my new Potato application](img/gotify-application-list.png)

### Testing

My application is now visible on the sidebar, let's now try to send a message. To push it, I can use `curl` and I need the token of the application.

```bash
curl "https://gotify.vezpi.me/message?token=<apptoken>" -F "title=Cooked!" -F "message=The potoaries are ready!" -F "priority=5"
```
I instantly received the notification on my mobile and on my browser.

I retried to send another message but with a lower priority: `-2`. I didn't get any notification in my browser, I see a slight differences between the two messages. On my mobile, only my watch received it, I don't see it on my screen, but I can find it on the notification center.
![Messages received on Gotify WebUI](img/gotify-messages-received.png)

### Android App

Here some screenshots from my Android device:
![Capture d’écran de l’application Android Gotify pour la page de connexion](img/gotify-android-first-login.png)

For some reason, a notification randomly pops up to tell me that I'm connected to Gotify:
![Capture d’écran de l’application Android Gotify avec les messages de test](img/gotify-android-test-messages.png)
### Conclusion

On the [documentation](https://gotify.net/docs/msgextras), I found some extras features, like adding images or click actions. In summary, it does the job, that's it. Easy installation process, the utilization is not hard, but I need to create an application for a token, then add this token anytime I want to push messages there.

## Ntfy

Ntfy seems very clean, let's install it and see what it got!

### Installation

Same story here  with `docker compose` on `dockerVM`. I create a new `ntfy` folder in `/appli/docker/` and I copy paste the `docker-compose.yml` template.

`docker-compose.yml`
```yaml
services:
  ntfy:
    image: binwiederhier/ntfy
    container_name: ntfy
    command:
      - serve
    volumes:
      - /appli/data/ntfy/data:/var/cache/ntfy
    environment:
      - TZ=Europe/Paris
      - NTFY_BASE_URL=https://ntfy.vezpi.me
      - NTFY_CACHE_FILE=/var/cache/ntfy/cache.db
      - NTFY_AUTH_FILE=/var/cache/ntfy/auth.db
      - NTFY_ATTACHMENT_CACHE_DIR=/var/cache/ntfy/attachments
      - NTFY_AUTH_DEFAULT_ACCESS=deny-all
      - NTFY_BEHIND_PROXY=true
      - NTFY_ENABLE_LOGIN=true
    user: 1000:1000
    networks:
      - web
    labels:
    - traefik.enable=true
    - traefik.http.routers.ntfy.rule=Host(`ntfy.vezpi.me`)
    - traefik.http.routers.ntfy.entrypoints=https
    - traefik.http.routers.ntfy.tls.certresolver=letsencrypt
    - traefik.http.services.ntfy.loadbalancer.server.port=80
    healthcheck:
      test: ["CMD-SHELL", "wget -q --tries=1 http://ntfy:80/v1/health -O - | grep -Eo '\"healthy\"\\s*:\\s*true' || exit 1"]
      interval: 60s
      timeout: 10s
      retries: 3
      start_period: 40s
    restart: unless-stopped

networks:
  web:
    external: true
```

I also create the persistent volume folder `/appli/data/ntfy/data/` in `dockerVM`:
```bash
mkdir -p /appli/data/ntfy/data/
```

The [documentation](https://docs.ntfy.sh/config/) is impressive, I tried to gather the config for a quickstart. I should be good to start the server.

Again here, I create a new domain for my Caddy reverse proxy plugin in OPNsense for the URL https://ntfy.vezpi.me.
```bash
$ docker compose up -d
[+] Running 4/4
 ✔ ntfy Pulled
   ✔ f18232174bc9 Already exists
   ✔ f5bf7a328fac Pull complete
   ✔ 572c745ef6c3 Pull complete
[+] Running 1/1
 ✔ Container ntfy  Started
```

✅ The URL https://ntfy.vezpi.me gives me to the Ntfy dashboard:
![Ntfy dashboard](img/ntfy-login-dashboard.png)

At start I don't have any user and none is created by default, as I denied all access to anonymous in the config, I need to create one.

To list the users, I can use this command:
```bash
$ docker exec -it ntfy ntfy user list
user * (role: anonymous, tier: none)
- no topic-specific permissions
- no access to any (other) topics (server config)
```

I create an user with admin privileges:
```bash
$ docker exec -it ntfy ntfy user add --role=admin vez
user vez added with role admin
```

I can now login into the WebUI, and I can now switch to dark mode, my eyes are grateful.

### Topics

In Ntfy there are no applications to create, but messages are grouped into topics, more readable than a token when sending messages. When the topic is created I can change the display name or send test messages. On the WebUI though I don't find any option to change the icon, where I can find this option in the Android App which is not really convenient.
![Example messages in Ntfy](img/ntfy-topic-messages.png)

### Testing

Sending a message is actually harder than I thought. Because I set up authentication, I also need to authenticate to send messages:
```
curl \
  -H "Title: Cooked!" \
  -H "Priority: high" \
  -d "The potatoes are ready!" \
  -u "vez:<password>" \
  https://ntfy.vezpi.me/patato
```

### Android App

Here are some screenshots of Ntfy Android App:
![Captures de l’application Android Ntfy](img/ntfy-android-app.png)
### Conclusion

Ntfy is a beautiful application with a really strong [documentation](https://docs.ntfy.sh/). The possibilities are endless and the list of integration is impressive. The installation was not hard but required a bit of more setup. The needs for CLI to configure users and permissions is not really convenient.

On the Android App, I regret that there is not a view to see all the messages from different topics. On the other hand on the WebUI, I wanted to set icons for each topics. What I found interesting was the possibility to have topics from different servers.

## Comparison

**Gotify** is simple, all users will have access to any applications. You don't need user credentials to push messages, only the application token. The Android App is effective, but personally while the icon is funny, I don't really like it.

**Ntfy** feels more advanced and complete, with fine grained permission. The UI is sleek yet still simple, the possibilities endless.

Overall, only small details make me favor Ntfy over Gotify, eg., having access to topics from different servers, ACL or be able to add emojis to the messages, but both applications are really good for the job.

## Implementing Real Scenario Notification

While I was setting up my CI/CD pipeline for my blog deployment, I wanted to be warned whenever something happens, let see how I can implement that with Ntfy.

### Access Control

I could use my `admin` user to either send messages from the pipeline and receive them on my Android device, while this is easier to setup, I want to implement least access privileges, which Ntfy allow. I will then create a dedicated user for my CI/CD pipeline and another for my Android device.

#### Pipeline User

This guy will only be allowed to send messages on the `blog` topic, I call it `gitea_blog`.
```bash
$ ntfy user add gitea_blog
user gitea_blog added with role user
$ ntfy access gitea_blog blog wo
granted write-only access to topic blog

user gitea_blog (role: user, tier: none)
- write-only access to topic blog
```

I quickly try to send a message on that topic:
```bash
$ curl -u gitea_blog:<password> -d "Message test from gitea_blog!" https://ntfy.vezpi.me/blog
{"id":"xIgwz9dr1w9Z","time":1749587681,"expires":1749630881,"event":"message","topic":"blog","message":"Message test from gitea_blog!"}
```

![Test d’envoi de messages sur le topic blog avec Ntfy  ](img/ntfy-testing-gitea-blog-user.png)
✅ Message received!

I also try to send a message on my test topic:
```bash
$ curl -u gitea_blog:<password> -d "Message test from gitea_blog!" https://ntfy.vezpi.me/potato
{"code":40301,"http":403,"error":"forbidden","link":"https://ntfy.sh/docs/publish/#authentication"}
```
❌ Denied as expected.

#### Android Device User

From my Android device I only want to receive messages, but on all topics. I create the user `android_s25u`:
```bash
$ ntfy user add android_s25u
user android_s25u added with role user
$ ntfy access android_s25u "*" ro
granted read-only access to topic *

user android_s25u (role: user, tier: none)
- read-only access to topic *
```

✅ After setting up the user on the Ntfy Android App, I can read my messages on the `blog` and on the testing one.

### Implementation

Now my users are setup, I want to add a `Notify` job in my CI/CD pipeline for the blog deployment in **Gitea**, you can find the full workflow in [this article]({{< ref "post/4-blog-deployment-ci-cd-pipeline-gitea-actions" >}}).

#### Create a Secret

To allow my Gitea Runner to use my `gitea_blog` user in its job, I want to create a secret. I explore the `Blog` Gitea repository `Settings`, then `Actions` > `Secrets` > `Add Secret`. Here I set the secret value with the `<user>:<password>` format:
![Add a secret in the blog Gitea repository](img/gitea-blog-ntfy-credentials.png)

### Write the `Notify` code

Now I can write the code which will send me a message when a new deployment occurs.

If the deployment is successful, the priority would be minimal, no notifications needed on my mobile, just for me to view the events in the Android Ntfy App if I need to.

If anything fails, I want to be notified on my mobile with higher priority. Ntfy allows me to add actions on my notifications, I will create 2 actions:
- **View Run**: Direct link to the workflow run in Gitea to see what happened.
- **Verify Blog**: Link to the blog to make sure it is still online.
```yaml
  Notify:
    needs: [Check-Rebuild, Build, Deploy-Staging, Test-Staging, Merge, Deploy-Production, Test-Production, Clean]
    runs-on: ubuntu
    if: always()
    env:
      NTFY_URL: https://ntfy.vezpi.me
      NTFY_TOPIC: blog
      NTFY_TOKEN: ${{ secrets.NTFY_CREDENTIALS }}
    steps:
      - name: Notify Workflow Result
        run: |
          if [[
            "${{ needs.Check-Rebuild.result }}" == "success" &&
           ("${{ needs.Build.result }}" == "success" || "${{ needs.Build.result }}" == "skipped") &&
            "${{ needs.Deploy-Staging.result }}" == "success" &&
            "${{ needs.Test-Staging.result }}" == "success" &&
            "${{ needs.Merge.result }}" == "success" &&
            "${{ needs.Deploy-Production.result }}" == "success" &&
            "${{ needs.Test-Production.result }}" == "success" &&
           ("${{ needs.Clean.result }}" == "success" || "${{ needs.Clean.result }}" == "skipped")
          ]]; then
            curl -H "Priority: min" \
                 -H "Tags: white_check_mark" \
                 -d "Blog workflow completed successfully." \
                 -u ${NTFY_TOKEN} \
                 ${NTFY_URL}/${NTFY_TOPIC}
          else
            curl -H "Priority: high" \
                 -H "Tags: x" \
                 -H "Actions: view, View Run, ${{ gitea.server_url }}/${{ gitea.repository }}/actions/runs/${{ gitea.run_number }}, clear=true; \
                              view, Verify Blog, https://blog.vezpi.com, clear=true" \
                 -d "Blog workflow failed!" \
                 -u ${NTFY_TOKEN} \
                 ${NTFY_URL}/${NTFY_TOPIC}
          fi
```

✅ Testing both cases work as expected
![Checking both test scenario in Ntfy WebUI](img/ntfy-testing-blog-notifications.png)

## Conclusion

After testing **Gotify** and **Ntfy**, I found my next notification system. They are both good for the job but I had to pick one and I have a little preference for Ntfy.

The application would be perfect if I could manage the users and access from the WebUI, also I would prefer to manage the topic's icon globally and not having to upload it from my mobile.

Anyway I'm very satisfied with the results on my first implementation and I look forward to add notification elsewhere!